0090-9556/97/2507-0893-0000$0/0
DRUG METABOLISM AND DISPOSITION
Copyright © 1997 by The American Society for Pharmacology and Experimental Therapeutics
Vol. 25, No. 7
SHORT COMMUNICATION
Decay Rates of Anti-HIV Dideoxynucleotides in Tissue Culture Systems: A
Simple Correction for the Effect of Cell Replication
 |
Abstract |
Measurement of intracellular drug levels in cell culture systems
can be of predictive value in establishing rational clinical dosage
schedules. Such in vitro measurements carried out with anti-HIV agents of the 2
,3
-dideoxynucleoside (ddN) class have shown
that many of the pharmacologically active ddNTP metabolites of these
agents have relatively long intracellular half-lives and little or no
host-cell cytotoxicity. As a consequence, replication of drug-exposed
cells continues at an unperturbed rate so that a systematic dilution
error occurs in the measurement of ddNTP decay half-times. The aim of
this study is to present a simple general formulation for the
correction of measured t1/2-values for ddNTPs
and for other agents with similar intracellular pharmacokinetic properties. Two factors of practical interest emerge: first, the error
is greater for agents with slow intracellular clearance rates than for
agents with rapid rates; and second, for cell lines with long doubling
times, the measured t1/2-values approach more closely to the true t1/2-values, until with the
extreme case (quiescent or "G0" cells), the
observed and true decay times are identical. The greatest dilution
errors are seen with adenodine-based agents such as ddATP and
2
-F-ddATP, while the smallest errors are seen with rapidly cleared
agents of the dideoxythymidine class.
 |
Article |
Purine and pyrimidine
ddNs1 play a major role in
the treatment of HIV and other viral infections. These compounds must
be phosphorylated intracellularly, most commonly to their ddNTPs, to
exert their antiviral effects. With few exceptions, however, the ddNTP
levels attained in human cells during clinical studies are too low for accurate measurement. As a consequence, studies of intracellular drug
levels are usually conducted in model systems (e.g.
virus-susceptible human cell lines adapted for rapid growth in tissue
culture) and then extrapolated to the clinical situation. In such
in vitro systems, radiolabeled drugs can be used, greatly
simplifying the chromatographic quantitation of active metabolites, and
cell sampling can be conducted under more rigidly controlled conditions
than feasible in a clinical study. The parameters of greatest practical interest derived from such in vitro studies are the
concentrations attained by ddNTPs in host cells and the duration of
ddNTP persistence over time. Such information can be of major
importance in establishing rational clinical dosage schedules (1-3).
Anti-HIV ddNs, unlike nucleoside analogs used in cancer chemotherapy,
typically are active at levels which, at least over short periods of
drug exposure, are not cytostatic or cytotoxic. Because of this absence
of toxicity, an unusual situation frequently occurs, i.e.
host cell function, including cell replication, continues at normal
rates in vitro; consequently, conventional pharmacokinetic parameters (e.g. half-times for intracellular nucleotide
accumulation and decay) require correction for the continuous dilution
resulting from cell replication proceeding at the same rate as for
unperturbed cells. In this short communication, we present a simple
general method for determining the corrected
t1/2 values for the decay of ddNTPs and apply it
to the adenosine-based agents ddATP and F-ddATP.
Materials and Methods. Chemicals.
ddI and F-ddA were provided by the Pharmaceutical Resources Branch,
National Cancer Institute. The radiolabeled compounds, [2
,3
-3H]ddI (30 Ci/mmol) and [5
-3H]F-ddA
(10 Ci/mmol), were obtained from Moravek Biochemicals (Brea, CA).
Radiopurity (
97%) was verified by HPLC before use.
Cells.
MOLT-4 cells were obtained from the American Type Culture Collection
(Rockville, MD) and were grown in RPMI 1640 tissue culture medium
supplemented with 10% heat-inactivated (56°C for 30 min) fetal
bovine serum, 45 µg/ml gentamycin, and 4 mM L-glutamine at 37°C in a humidified atmosphere of 95% air/5% CO2.
Cells were verified to be in logarithmic growth at the time of use (a
30-hr doubling time at an initial cell density of <1.5 × 106 cells/ml).
Metabolism Studies.
Ten-milliliter aliquots of cell suspensions were incubated with a 10 µM concentration of either [3H]ddI or
[3H]F-ddA (5 µCi/ml) for 12 hr. Cells were then washed
and resuspended in drug-free medium, and aliquots removed over the next
60 hr for determination of intracellular concentrations of ddATP or F-ddATP, using ion-exchange Partisil 10-SAX HPLC chromatography as
previously described (4). During the course of the study, cells were
maintained in logarithmic growth (i.e. <1.5 × 106 cells/ml) either by diluting the cultures with
additional fresh medium or by removing the cells by centrifugation and
resuspending the cell pellet in an appropriate volume of fresh medium.
Theoretical.
Assuming the simplest case (i.e. cells in exponential growth
and a total amount, M, of intracellular ddNTP decaying by a
first-order process with a rate constant k), then
|
(1)
|
But, typically, the concentration, C, of ddNTP, is the
actual measured variable (e.g. pmol/106 cells).
This concentration decreases with an experimentally determined rate
constant
, both because of the loss of total ddNTP and because of
ddNTP dilution by the simultaneous increase in total cell number, N. If we assume that the cells are in exponential growth
with a rate constant
, and note that M = NC, then
|
(2)
|
Since dC/dt = 
C and
dN/dt =
N, a simple result is obtained
that allows correction of measured ddNTP decay for cell growth, i.e.
|
(3)
|
(For an alternate derivation of eq. 3, see the Appendix.)
Furthermore, if we define tm, the experimentally
measured half-time, as ln2/
, and the experimentally determined cell
doubling time, tD, as ln2/
, then
|
(4)
|
Results and Discussion.
Two features of practical interest arise from the formulation developed
herein. The first of these is that the correction is greater for agents
with slower intracellular clearance rates than for agents with more
rapid rates. Thus, for F-ddATP (fig. 1),
tm = 19 hr;
tD for MOLT-4 cells = 30 hr. Consequently,
1/t1/2 = 1/19
1/30, so that
t1/2 = 52 hr, a 174% increase over the measured
value. However, for ddGTP, previously studied in this laboratory under
the same conditions and in the same cell line (table 1),
tm = 4.2 hr, giving t1/2 = 4.9 hr, a difference of only 17% from the experimentally determined
value.

View larger version (17K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
|
Fig. 1.
Intracellular levels of ddATP and F-ddATP
after incubation with ddI and F-ddA.
MOLT-4 cells were treated with ddI or F-ddA (10 µM; 5 µCi/ml) for
12 hr, as described more fully in Materials and Methods. Experiments shown were conducted independently twice, with little variation in results. Results shown are the average of dulplicate values from a single experiment. The measured half-times (i.e. tm values) were calculated from the slopes of the
weighted lines generated by linear regression analysis.
|
|
The second feature of interest is that, with long cell doubling
times, tm approaches more closely to
t1/2, until, with the extreme case (quiescent or
"G0" cells), tm = t1/2 (i.e. the observed and true
decay half-times are identical). This situation occurs with
nonstimulated human PBM cells, a test system which, because of its high
percentage of mature T-lymphocytes, approximates the predominant
circulating host cells for HIV-1 in vivo. However, this
situation is not observed with the majority of HIV-1 test systems,
human lymphoblastoid cell lines selected for rapid growth in tissue
culture (e.g. MOLT-4, CEM, ATH8, MT-2, and MT-4), with cell
doubling times in the range of 20-48 hr. Even though quiescent or
"resting" PBM cells are used in some studies (5), the model system
more frequently used is PBM cells activated before drug exposure with
mitogens, such as PHA. Activation results in cell progression into
S-phase and subsequent mitosis, a system more closely analogous to
actively replicating lymph node T-cells before maturation and release
into the circulation. In fig. 2 is shown the
difference between measured and actual drug half-times that would be
obtained for agents with tm (measured half-time)
values ranging from 5 to 20 hr. For an agent with a
tm value of 15 hr in a very slowly replicating
cell line (tD = 60 hr), the true decay half-time
would be 20 hr, a difference of only 33% from the experimental value.
However, for an agent with the same tm in
rapidly replicating cells (e.g. tD = 24 hr, a rate closer to that seen with a typical host cell line for
HIV-1 studies in vitro), the true decay half-time would be
40 hr, a difference of 167%.

View larger version (15K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
|
Fig. 2.
Relationship between measured half-times
(tm values) and actual t1/2 values in cell
lines with replication times (tD values) ranging from 24 to
60 hr.
Curves were generated from the equation 1/t1/2 = 1/tm 1/tD.
|
|
From a practical point of view, it follows that, in the case of ddNTPs
with short decay half-times, the correction factor is small and thus
can be neglected. For example, for the thymidine-based agent D4T,
half-times ~3.3 hr have been reported for studies conducted in
PHA/PBM and CEM cells (table 1). Assuming a typical doubling time of 30 hr for CEM cells, the actual t1/2 for this agent
in the latter cell line would have been 3.7 hr. The difference between these times would be of slight significance relative to the variation seen in typical biological experimentation, and the uncertainty of an
average value for the replication times for the mixture of lymphocyte
and other cell types acting as host cells for the virus in
vivo. For more slowly catabolized agents, however, such as the
-L-enantiomer of 3TC-TP (table 1) or the adenosine-based agents ddATP and F-ddATP [fig. 1 and table 1], the correction factors
are substantial and probably should be applied if data are subsequently
to be used in the design of appropriate clinical dose schedules.
It should be noted that this simple formulation will require
modification for compounds whose pharmacological properties are more
complex than those of ddNs and their active metabolites, ddNTPs. One
major simplifying factor for ddNs is that ddNTPs, unlike dNTPs such as
araCTP, cannot, because of the absence of a 3
-hydroxyl group, form
internucleotide linkages in cellular DNA; thus, no correction is
necessary for loss by this route. Furthermore, the 5
-phosphates of
most ddNs cross cell membranes poorly; therefore, no detectable loss of
intracellularly generated ddNTPs occurs by outward diffusion. One major
and apparently unique exception to the latter generalization is the
widely used ddN AZT: in human cells, the 5
-monophosphate of this
compound is an extremely poor substrate for the kinase catalyzing its
further phosphorylation to AZT-5
-diphosphate, with the result that the monophosphate accumulates to sufficiently high levels intracellularly to diffuse back unchanged to the medium or plasma (6). As a consequence, it has long been recognized that more complex
pharmacokinetic models are required to describe the intracellular
behavior of this compound (6).
Another relevant question is whether the kinetic behavior of ddNTPs in
uninfected lymphoblasts adequately represents ddNTP behavior in
virus-infected cells. Little information seems to be available on this
point. In an early study (7), we noted that the metabolism of ddC was
identical in HIV-infected and uninfected ATH8 cells. In a study
comparing the
-D- and
-L-enantiomers of
3TC-TP, Cammack et al. (9) similarly found no significant difference between the tm values found in
uninfected and HIV-infected PHA/PBM cells (table 1). However, as
investigators have recognized in other contexts, it can be misleading
to extrapolate conclusions from the lightly infected cells used in
laboratory tissue culture experiments to the massive HIV infections
seen in vivo. Studies using high multiplicity of viral
infection, in cell lines susceptible to HIV-induced cytopathic effects,
would be required to settle this point.
 |
Appendix |
Alternate derivation for eq. 3: C depends
on both cell number and time, i.e.
|
(A1)
|
The total time rate of change in C(N, t) is thus
|
(A2)
|
The pure metabolic decay constant is defined when cell volume is
constant, i.e.
|
(A3)
|
Exponential cell growth is
|
(A4)
|
where N = number of cells in culture. At a fixed
moment in time, C and N are related by
|
(A5)
|
where M is the total mass of agent. Thus,
|
(A6)
|
Substituting (A3), (A4), and (A6) into (A2),
|
(A7)
|
This last expression is the form fit with concentration data (with
a single exponential constant,
). Hence,
or
Gurpreet S. Ahluwalia
Robert L. Dedrick
John S. Driscoll
Paul F. Morrison
Wen-Yi Gao
David G. Johns
Laboratory of Medicinal Chemistry (G.S.A., J.S.D.,
D.G.J.),
Division of Basic Sciences, Experimental
Retrovirology Branch (W.-Y.G.), Division of Clinical
Sciences, National Cancer Institute; and
Biomedical
Engineering and Instrumentation Program (R.L.D.,
P.F.M.), National Center for Research Resources, National
Institutes of Health
 |
Footnotes |
Received September 11, 1996; accepted March 25, 1997.
Send reprint requests to: Dr. David G. Johns, Building
37, Room 5B22, Laboratory of Medicinal Chemistry, Division of Basic
Sciences, National Cancer Institute/National Institutes of Health,
Bethesda, MD 20892-4255.
 |
Abbreviations |
Abbreviations used are:
ddN, 2
,3
-dideoxynucleoside;
HIV, human immunodeficiency virus;
ddNTP, ddN-5
-triphosphate;
ddATP, 2
,3
-dideoxyadenosine-5
-triphosphate;
F-ddATP, 2
-
-fluoro-ddATP;
ddI, 2
,3
-dideoxyinosine;
F-ddA, 2
-
-fluoro-2
,3
-dideoxyadenosine;
ddGTP, 2
,3
-dideoxyguanosine-5
-triphosphate;
PBM cells, peripheral blood
mononuclear cells;
D4T, 2
,3
-didehydro-3
-deoxythymidine;
PHA, phytohemagglutinin;
tm, measured
(uncorrected)t1/2;
tD, cell doubling time;
3TC-TP, 2
-deoxy-3
-thiacytidine-5
-triphosphate;
AZT, 3
-azido-3
-deoxythymidine;
ddC, 2
,3
-dideoxycytidine.
 |
References |
| 1.
|
Y. Törnevik,
B. Jacobsson,
S. Britton, and
S. Eriksson:
Intracellular metabolism of 3 -azidothymidine in isolated human peripheral blood mononuclear cells.
AIDS Res. Human Retroviruses
7,
751-759 (1991)[Medline].
|
| 2.
|
Z. Zhu,
H.-T. Ho,
M. J. Hitchcock, and
J.-P. Sommadossi:
Cellular pharmacology of 2 ,3 -didehydro-2 ,3 -dideoxythymidine (D4T) in human peripheral blood mononuclear cells.
Biochem. Pharmacol.
39,
R15-R19 (1990)[Medline].
|
| 3.
|
R. Yarchoan,
H. Mitsuya,
R. V. Thomas,
J. M. Pluda,
N. R. Hartman,
C.-F. Perno,
K. S. Marczyk,
J.-P. Allain,
D. G. Johns, and
S. Broder:
In vivo activity against HIV and favorable toxicity profile of 2 ,3 -dideoxyinosine.
Science
245,
412-415 (1989)[Abstract/Free Full Text].
|
| 4.
|
R. Masood,
G. S. Ahluwalia,
D. A. Cooney,
A. Fridland,
V. E. Marquez,
J. S. Driscoll,
Z. Hao,
H. Mitsuya,
C.-F. Perno,
S. Broder, and
D. G. Johns:
Fluoro-2 ,3 -dideoxyarabinosyladenine: a metabolically stable analogue of the antiretroviral agent 2 ,3 -dideoxyadenosine.
Mol. Pharmacol.
37,
590-596 (1990)[Abstract].
|
| 5.
| H.-T. Ho, K. L. Woods, M. Mansuri, and M. J. M. Hitchcock:
Activation of 2 -fluoro-2 ,3 -dideoxyarabinosyladenine (FddA), an
anti-HIV agent, in both quiescent and PHA-activated human peripheral
blood mononuclear cells (PBMC). Antiviral Res. 15 (Suppl. 1), 95 (1991).
|
| 6.
|
A. Fridland,
M. C. Connelly, and
R. Ashmun:
Relationship of deoxynucleotide changes to inhibition of DNA synthesis induced by the antiretroviral agent 3 -azido-3 -deoxythymidine and release of its monophosphate by human lymphoid cells (CCRF-CEM).
Mol. Pharmacol.
37,
665-670 (1990)[Abstract].
|
| 7.
|
D. A. Cooney,
M. Dalal,
H. Mitsuya,
J. B. McMahon,
M. Nadkarni,
J. Balzarini,
S. Broder, and
D. G. Johns:
Initial studies on the cellular pharmacology of 2 ,3 -dideoxycytidine, an inhibitor of HTLV-III infectivity.
Biochem. Pharmacol.
35,
2065-2068 (1986)[Medline].
|
| 8.
|
H.-T. Ho and
M. J. M. Hitchcock:
Cellular pharmacology of 2 ,3 -dideoxy-2 ,3 -didehydrothymidine, a nucleoside analog active against human immunodeficiency virus.
Antimicrob. Agents Chemother.
33,
844-849 (1989)[Abstract/Free Full Text].
|
| 9.
|
N. Cammack,
P. Rouse,
C. L. P. Marr,
P. J. Reid,
R. E. Boehme,
J. A. V. Coates,
C. R. Penn, and
J. M. Cameron:
Cellular metabolism of ( )enantiomeric 2 -deoxy-3 -thiacytidine.
Biochem. Pharmacol.
43,
2059-2064 (1992)[Medline].
|
| 10.
|
G. Ahluwalia,
D. A. Cooney,
N. R. Hartman,
H. Mitsuya,
R. Yarchoan,
A. Fridland,
S. Broder, and
D. G. Johns:
Anomalous accumulation and decay of 2 ,3 -dideoxyadenosine-5 -triphosphate in human T-cell cultures exposed to the anti-HIV drug 2 ,3 -dideoxyinosine.
Drug Metab. Dispos.
21,
369-376 (1993)[Abstract].
|
| 11.
|
L. L. Bondoc, Jr.,
G. Ahluwalia,
D. A. Cooney,
N. R. Hartman,
D. G. Johns, and
A. Fridland:
Metabolic pathways for the activation of the antiviral agent 2 ,3 -dideoxyguanosine in human lymphoid cells.
Mol. Pharmacol.
42,
525-530 (1992)[Abstract].
|
| 12.
|
Z. Hao,
E. E. Stowe,
G. Ahluwalia,
D. C. Baker,
A. K. Hebbler,
C. Chisena,
S. M. Musser,
J. A. Kelley,
C.-F. Perno,
D. G. Johns, and
D. A. Cooney:
Characterization of 2 ,3 -dideoxycytidine diphosphocholine and 2 ,3 -dideoxycytidine diphosphoethanolamine.
Drug Metab. Dispos.
21,
738-744 (1993)[Abstract].
|
| 13.
|
R. L. Blakley,
F. C. Harwood, and
K. D. Huff:
Cytostatic effects of 2 ,3 -dideoxyribonucleosides on transformed human hemopoietic cell lines.
Mol. Pharmacol.
37,
328-332 (1990)[Abstract].
|
| 14.
|
M. J. M. Hitchcock,
K. Woods,
H. DeBoeck, and
H.-T. Ho:
Biochemical pharmacology of 2 -fluoro-2 ,3 -dideoxyarabinosyladenine, an inhibitor of HIV with improved metabolic and chemical stability over 2 ,3 -dideoxyadenosine.
Antiviral Chem. Chemother.
1,
319-327 (1990).
|
Copyright © 1997 by The American Society for Pharmacology and Experimental Therapeutics