![]() |
|
|
| Abstract |
|---|
|
|
|---|
A key question faced by health risk assessors is whether the mouse or the rat is an appropriate animal model for TCA-, TCE-, or PCE-induced liver tumors in humans. Species differences in the metabolism and pharmacokinetics of TCE and PCE have been reviewed by Bull (2000
) and Volkel et al. (1998
), respectively. Metabolism of TCE and PCE is qualitatively, but not quantitatively, similar in rodents and humans. Mice have a considerably greater capacity to oxidize each chemical to TCA via hepatic cytochromes P450 than do humans. Rats are intermediate in this regard (Green and Prout, 1985
; Reitz et al., 1996
). TCA itself is poorly metabolized (Yu et al., 2000
).
TCE-exposed mice exhibit relatively high peak blood TCA levels, which would appear to correlate with the species' susceptibility to liver tumors. Areas under blood TCA concentration versus time curves (AUCs), however, are reported to be comparable in mice and rats administered equivalent doses of TCE (Larson and Bull, 1992
). A physiologically based pharmacokinetic (PBPK) model for TCE even predicted comparable plasma TCA AUCs for similarly exposed mice and humans (Fisher, 2000
). Since blood TCA elimination half-lives vary from 7 h in mice to 90 to 100 h in humans (Muller et al., 1972
), the relatively slow systemic clearance of TCA by humans apparently offsets the mouse's greater capacity to produce TCA. Muller et al. (1972
) stated that 86 to 90% of TCA in human blood was bound to plasma proteins, but no binding data were included in their paper. Templin et al. (1995
) subsequently reported that rat plasma had approximately one-half the TCA binding capacity of human plasma.
Plasma protein binding may play a major role in target tissue exposure and species-specific susceptibility of animals to TCA hepatocarcinogenicity. The concentration of active moiety (TCA) at the target (hepatocyte) and the length of time it is present are major determinants of the magnitude of carcinogenic action. Species differences in plasma protein binding of a highly bound compound should be reflected in the concentration of unbound chemical in the plasma and target tissue. Relatively low plasma binding in rodents would result in relatively high exposure of their hepatocytes to TCA. The objective of the current work was to characterize and to compare the binding of TCA to mouse, rat, and human plasma in vitro. The data were analyzed to clarify the mechanistic basis of species differences in binding.
| Materials and Methods |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Animals. Adult, male Sprague-Dawley (S-D) rats were supplied by Charles River Laboratories, Inc. (Wilmington, MA). The rats were maintained on a 12-h light/dark cycle at 2123°C and 40 to 50% humidity in an AAALAC-approved animal care facility. A diet of Laboratory Rodent Diet (PMI Feeds Inc., Richmond, IN) and tap water was provided ad libitum.
Plasma. Frozen, heparinized, pooled mouse and rat plasmas were obtained from Harlan Bioproducts for Science (Indianapolis, IN). Donor strain and sex were not specified. Blood was taken by cardiac puncture from the S-D rats to obtain fresh plasma. This plasma was stored at 4°C until use. Its binding performance was compared with thawed rat plasma at high [6,130 µM (1,000 µg/ml)] and low [0.61 µM (0.1 µg/ml)] TCA concentrations and found to be equivalent (data not shown). Pooled human plasma with EDTA as an anticoagulant was obtained frozen from Bioreclamation Inc. (Hicksville, NY). All plasma samples were filtered through 0.45-µm Millipore filters (Millipore Corporation, Bedford, MA) to remove precipitated fibrinogen. Total protein and albumin contents of plasma samples were measured by the biuret and the bromcresol green colorimetric methods, respectively.
Plasma Protein Binding Measurement. Binding of TCA to plasma constituents was determined by equilibrium dialysis, using a five-sample cell system from Spectrum Laboratories (Rancho Dominguez, CA). Each cell was divided by a methyl ester cellulose dialysis membrane (45 mm, 1214,000 mol. wt. cutoff) to produce two 1.3-ml reservoirs. One ml of plasma was injected into one reservoir. TCA in physiological buffer (100 mM sodium phosphate, 13 mM potassium phosphate, and 75 mM sodium chloride in triple-filtered deionized water, adjusted to pH 7.4) was injected into the other reservoir. Three replicates (n = 3) of 13 TCA concentrations were tested, ranging from 0.06 to 6,130 µM (0.01 to 1,000 µg/ml). The cells were sealed, submerged, and rotated in a 37°C water bath for 60 min. Pilot experiments revealed that TCA binding reached equilibrium by 60 min (data not shown). Plasma and buffer temperature and pH were maintained at 37°C and 7.4, respectively, to approximate the plasma binding environment in vivo. Mean analyte recoveries ± S.D. (n = 3) were 81 ± 18%, 99 ± 16%, and 82 ± 11% for human, rat, and mouse plasma, respectively.
At equilibrium, the concentration of TCA on the plasma side of the dialysis cells represented the total concentration (Ctotal), whereas that on the buffer side represented the free concentration (Cfree). The bound concentration could then be calculated as the difference between the total and free concentrations (Cbound = Ctotal - Cfree). A fluid shift of 10% of the original volume occurred in the direction of the buffer side of each cell. This behavior was compensated for by dividing the total concentration by 0.9 and the free side concentration by 1.1.
TCA Analysis. Aliquots were drawn from each side of the dialysis cell and processed for gas chromatographic (GC) analysis. The TCA in each sample was esterified with acidified methanol and extracted into n-hexane by the GC-electron capture procedure of Abbas and Fisher (1997
). Chromatography conditions were as follows: HP-5 capillary column (0.25 mm x 30 m) with nitrogen as the carrier gas at a flow rate of 2.5 ml/min; inlet temperature = 260°C; detector temperature = 230°C; and oven temperature = 50°C. TCA standards were prepared daily and analyzed concurrently with the plasma- and buffer-side samples.
Model Fitting. Plots of the bound fraction as a function of the free TCA concentration were fitted to different binding models to generate three parameter estimates: the number of binding sites per molecule of protein, N; the binding capacity, Bmax [N x P, the binding protein concentration (µM)]; and the dissociation constant Kd (µM). Attempts were made to fit the data to expressions describing a single, saturable binding process (eq. 1), a saturable and a nonsaturable, linear binding process (eq. 2), and two independent, saturable binding processes (eq. 3).
![]() | (1) |
![]() | (2) |
![]() | (3) |
Fit of the data to the first model (eq. 1) was evaluated, since at least one saturable binding process was apparent (Fig. 1). The second model (eq. 2) was based on the hypothesis of Taira and Terada (1985
), who proposed that serum albumin is capable of low-capacity (saturable, nonlinear), high-specificity as well as high-capacity, low-specificity (nonsaturable, linear) anion binding. The linear term of this model is governed by a unitless binding coefficient (A). This equation was used to fit TCA binding to rat plasma in vitro by Yu et al. (2000
).
|
| Results |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Plots of bound versus free TCA are pictured in Fig. 1. The proportion of bound to free is substantially higher for human plasma than for the rodent plasmas, particularly at the lower TCA concentrations. Mouse plasma consistently exhibits the lowest binding capacity. The proportion of bound to free progressively decreases in all three species at the nominal TCA level of 307 µM, indicative of the onset of saturation of binding.
The fraction of TCA bound as a function of its nominal concentration is shown in Fig. 2. Human plasma exhibited the most pronounced binding over the entire range of concentrations. Binding was highest (86.8%) at the lowest testable TCA level (0.12 µM). The bound fraction remained relatively constant, with a mean of 81.6% over a 3.7-order of magnitude increase in TCA concentration. Binding diminished from a maximum of 66.6% for the rat and 46.6% for the mouse to quasi-steady-state levels of 38.6 and 19.1%, respectively. Saturation of binding was manifest in both species, as it was in humans, by precipitous decreases in percentage bound at TCA concentrations exceeding 307 µM. Another binding domain apparently occurred for each species at low concentrations. The fraction of bound TCA in mouse and rat plasma declined as TCA concentration increased from 0.12 to 0.30 µM (Fig. 2). Binding to human plasma at 0.12 µM exceeded that at 0.18 µM. Further characterization of this second apparent binding component was not possible due to our analytical limitations.
|
Attempts were made to fit the free and bound TCA concentration data to each of the three binding models to generate the best estimates of Bmax, affinity, and N. The preferred model would be one that adequately described the saturable processes in the low and high TCA concentration ranges. Estimates of the binding parameters for the saturable site with eq. 1 were used as initial estimates for fitting data to the two-saturable process model (eq. 3). Unfortunately, a reasonable estimate of CV% and AIC values was not possible due to an inadequate number of data points to fully describe the apparent saturable process at the lower end of the TCA concentration range. Attempts to fit the mouse and human data to the saturable plus nonsaturable model (eq. 2) were unsuccessful. The best fits were obtained for each species (Fig. 3) with the single saturable binding process model (eq. 1).
|
Fitting was performed using total plasma protein and albumin concentrations. Much better fits were obtained for all species when albumin was used. For this reason, the albumin concentrations were used to define P. P values for human, rat, and mouse plasma were 239, 190, and 196 µM, respectively. N was found to be highest for human plasma (2.97), followed by rat (1.49) and mouse (0.17) plasma. Bmax was highest for the human and lowest for the mouse. Species differences in Kd values were not biologically significant (Table 1).
|
| Discussion |
|---|
|
|
|---|
In our study, some characteristics of the binding of TCA to plasma proteins differed from one species to another. The primary difference we observed was the number of binding sites per molecule of protein. Model fitting yielded N values that ranged from 2.97 for humans to 0.17 for mice. The value of <1 suggested the presence in mouse plasma of other ligands competing for the TCA binding site. Dissociation constants did not differ significantly from one species to another, however, reflecting similar affinities. Lin (1989
) likewise saw little difference in the affinities of human and rat plasma for diflunisal [5-(2',4'-difluorophenyl) salicylic acid], but found three distinct binding sites in human plasma and one in rat plasma.
In the current study, the relatively high binding capacity of human plasma for TCA was a product of its larger number of binding sites and its somewhat higher concentration of albumin. Plasma albumin concentrations are modestly higher in humans (Zhou et al., 2001
). These investigators observed a reasonable degree of correlation between bound 5,6-dimethylxanthenone-4-acetic acid and the albumin content of plasma of humans, rats, rabbits, and mice. Fits of our TCA data to a saturable binding model were best when albumin rather than total protein was used. This observation is consistent with the concept that water-soluble, anionic compounds bind predominantly to albumin (du Souich et al., 1993
).
The fraction of TCA bound to plasma proteins was both species- and TCA concentration-dependent. Our mean percentage bound values of 82% and 39% for humans and rats, respectively, are quite similar to values reported for these species by Templin et al. (1995
). Our mouse value of 19%, however, is substantially lower than the 34 to 55% measured by Templin et al. (1993
). The reason for this disparity is unclear, although Templin et al. (1993
) used Scatchard analysis over a narrower range of TCA concentrations to estimate binding parameters.
Species differences in plasma protein binding of TCA can significantly affect tissue disposition of the carcinogen. Although TCA is fully charged at physiological pH, it is apparently conveyed rapidly across cell membranes by a bidirectional monocarboxylate transporter (Poole and Halestrap, 1993
). Jackson and Halestrap (1996
) demonstrated efficient transport of chloroacetate and dichloroacetate by isolated rat hepatocytes. TCA is distributed uniformly outside the vasculature and does not bind appreciably to the liver or to any other tissue (Schultz et al., 1999
). The concentration of TCA at the target site (i.e., hepatocyte) should therefore be largely governed by the concentration of free chemical in the plasma. The lowest chronic oral TCE dose to produce liver tumors in mice is 1,000 mg/kg (Bull, 2000
). Peak blood TCA levels in B6C3F1 mice and in F344 rats gavaged with 1,200 mg of TCE/kg are reported to be
580 and 300 µM, respectively (Abbas and Fisher, 1997
; M. Lumpkin, S. Muralidhara, C. White, J. Fisher, C. Dallas, and J. Bruckner, manuscript submitted for publication). PBPK modeling by the latter researchers forecast peak blood TCA levels of 470 µM in humans who ingest 1,200 mg of TCE/kg. If these blood levels are equated to nominal TCA concentrations in our in vitro system, the free fraction of TCA in mouse plasma will be about 4-fold higher than in rat plasma and 5-fold higher than in human plasma. These results are consistent with the unique susceptibility of mice to TCA-induced liver tumors, and call into question the practice of using total blood levels of TCA in mice under bioassay conditions as dosimeters for prediction of human liver cancer risk.
It is apparent from data in the current report that the percentage of plasma TCA binding increases in each species as the TCA concentration decreases. At the lowest level we could test [0.12 µM (0.02 µg/ml)],
87% binding occurred in human plasma. PBPK modeling predicted that an oral bolus dose of 0.02 mg of TCE/kg would produce a prolonged TCA Cmax of 0.02 to 0.03 µg/ml, with only 0.005 to 0.006 µg of free TCA/ml in human blood (M. Lumpkin, S. Muralidhara, C. White, J. Fisher, C. Dallas, and J. Bruckner, manuscript submitted for publication). Likewise, a 70-kg adult who drinks 2 liters of water daily containing 700 parts per billion of TCE would receive 0.02 mg/kg of the chemical, assuming 100% absorption. Our work suggests that percentage binding of TCA may approach 100% at even lower levels of exposure. We observed convergence of the fraction bound to plasma of all three species at 0.12 µM TCA, suggesting binding to the same site. Future experiments could clarify the extent and species specificity of plasma binding of a range of trace levels of TCA. In light of the foregoing, the validity of using total blood levels of TCA as a dose metric when extrapolating from high-dose, animal bioassay data to predict human environmental cancer risks needs to be re-examined.
Michael H. Lumpkin
James V. Bruckner
Jerry L. Campbell
Cham E. Dallas
Catherine A. White
Jeffrey W. Fisher
Clayton Group Services, Inc., Kennesaw, GA (M.H.L.); Department of Pharmaceutical and Biomedical Sciences, College of Pharmacy, University of Georgia, Athens, GA (J.V.B.,C.E.D., C.A.W.); and Department of Environmental Health Science, College of Agricultural and Environmental Sciences, University of Georgia, Athens, GA (J.L.C., J.F.W)
| Footnotes |
|---|
1 Abbreviations used are: TCA, trichloroacetic acid; A, binding coefficient; AAALAC, American Association for Accreditation of Laboratory Animal Care; AIC, Akaike Information Criterion; AUC, area under the concentration versus time curve; Bmax, maximum binding capacity; Cbound, bound concentration; Cfree, free concentration; Ctotal, total concentration; GC, gas chromatography; N, number of binding site per molecule of protein; P, binding protein concentration; PBPK, physiologically based pharmacokinetic; PCE, perchloroethylene; S-D, Sprague-Dawley (rats); TCE, trichloroethylene. ![]()
Address correspondence to: Dr. Jeffrey W. Fisher, Department of Environmental Health Sciences, College of Agricultural and Environmental Sciences, University of Georgia, D.W. Brooks Drive, Athens, GA 30602-2354. E-mail: jwfisher{at}arches.uga.edu
| References |
|---|
|
|
|---|
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||