Heme A, an obligatory cofactor in eukaryotic cytochrome c oxidase, is produced from heme B (protoheme) via two enzymatic reactions catalyzed by heme O synthase and heme A synthase. Heme O synthase is responsible for the addition of a farnesyl moiety, while heme A synthase catalyzes the oxidation of a methyl substituent to an aldehyde. We have cloned the heme O synthase and heme A synthase genes from Bacillus subtilis (ctaB and ctaA) and overexpressed them in Escherichia coli to probe the oxidative mechanism of heme A synthase. Because E. coli does not naturally produce or utilize heme A, this strategy effectively decoupled heme A biosynthesis from the native electron transfer pathway and heme A transport, allowing us to observe two previously unidentified hemes. We utilized HPLC, UV/visible spectroscopy, and tandem mass spectrometry to identify these novel hemes as derivatives of heme O containing an alcohol or a carboxylate moiety at position C8 on pyrrole ring D. We interpret these derivatives to be the putative alcohol intermediate and an overoxidized byproduct of heme A synthase. Because we have shown that all hemes produced by heme A synthase require O(2) for their synthesis, we propose that heme A synthase catalyzes the oxidation of the C8 methyl to an aldehyde group via two discrete monooxygenase reactions.