The toxicity of quinones is believed to be mediated via redox cycling involving formation of semiquinone radicals which autoxidize to form active oxygen species. However, when the cytotoxicity of benzoquinones was compared using freshly isolated rat hepatocytes, benzoquinones which did not mediate oxidative stress were highly toxic. Thus, the benzoquinone analogs in decreasing order of cytotoxicity were 2-CH3-, 2-Br-, unsubstituted, 2,6-(CH3)2-, 2,5-(CH3)2-, and 2,3,5-(CH3)3-benzoquinone. Cellular thiols were rapidly depleted and glutathione (GSH) was converted to a quinone conjugate without oxidation to glutathione disulfide. No increase in cyanide-resistant respiration was observed and benzoquinone-induced cytotoxicity was not enhanced by inactivation of catalase or glutathione reductase. In contrast, duroquinone [2,3,5,6-(CH3)4-benzoquinone], which stimulated cyanide-resistant respiration and GSH oxidation, was only cytotoxic when catalase or glutathione reductase was inactivated. These results suggest that alkylation and/or oxidative stress may be important mechanisms in the cytotoxicity of benzoquinone derivatives.