1. Experimental data previously used to support an electron/proton transfer mechanism for oxidative dealkylation of amines by P450 are critically analysed with the conclusion that the mechanistic evidence is indecisive. 2. A new mechanistic criterion recently proposed to distinguish between electron/proton transfer and hydrogen atom transfer mechanisms is discussed. It is based on isotope effect profiles determined for the deprotonation of a series of para-substituted N-methyl-N-trideuteriomethyl)aniline cation radicals by pyridine and for hydrogen atom abstraction from the corresponding neutral amines by the tert-butoxyl radical. These reactions model the steps proposed in the two P450 mechanisms. 3. Isotope effect profiles measured for the demethylation of substituted NN-bis(dideuteriomethyl)anilines by four different forms of P450 were found to be experimentally indistinguishable from the hydrogen atom transfer profile, and distinctly different from the cation radical deprotonation profile. This provides strong evidence that P450 oxidatively dealkylates the amines by a hydrogen atom transfer mechanism and not by an electron/proton transfer mechanism.